Thanks for joining me on our Create Your Own JAFF Adventure! Just starting? You can catch up on previous posts collected here: https://austenvariations.com/category/sarah-courtney/ . Last week, Elizabeth saw Mr. Wickham at the park and told him about her dance at the Netherfield Ball with Mr. Darcy, then returned to the Gardiners’ and greeted Colonel Fitzwilliam and Miss Darcy. When she spoke with Miss Darcy, readers voted that she should tell Miss Darcy about meeting an acquaintance at the park, and so that is where we will start this week!
If you’d prefer the third person version, you can read it here. There’s a link at the bottom of the intro part that will jump you to the newest part. Just don’t forget to come back and comment to tell me what Elizabeth should do next!

“In fact, although I know very few people here aside from my aunt and uncle, I saw an acquaintance from Meryton in the park.”
“I hope . . . I hope it was a pleasant meeting.” Miss Darcy looks down at her feet. “I would not have thought . . .” She trails off.
“You would not have thought?” you encourage her.
“From what my brother had said, I would not have thought many of your neighbours in Meryton would spend time in London, especially during hunting season.”
Of course Mr. Darcy would speak of the few connections of people in Hertfordshire. “It was a lieutenant in the militia, Mr. Wickham, who is currently stationed in Meryton.” Mr. Wickham spoke fondly of his days with Georgiana in her youth, but you wonder if the girl will acknowledge the acquaintance now. From what he said, you have the impression the girl has grown too proud to speak of a steward’s son.
Miss Darcy blushes. “Mr. Wickham! I did not realize you knew him.”
“A little.” You cock your head, considering. From Mr. Wickham’s words of her pride, you had not expected this reaction, but rather something more like irritation or disregard. Her blush makes you think of Kitty’s reaction when Lydia teases her about Mr. Denny. Perhaps Miss Darcy seemed proud and distant to Mr. Wickham because she has a little schoolgirl infatuation for him?
How much does Miss Darcy know about Mr. Wickham’s lost inheritance? Does she know what her brother did? Likely not. Brothers never share much with sisters about such things, especially not when there is such a difference in age between them.
“Would you care for some tea?” you ask. “Or would you prefer to see your room? I would go up to change for dinner soon, but I suppose you do not have your things, do you?”
“I do, in fact!” the younger girl says. “I was ready to rush to my brother’s aid when I heard he was injured here, but my cousin forced me to wait an extra few minutes while he asked my maid to follow with some clothing for me, and now I am glad he did, if I will be staying until my brother is well. I would like to go to my room, please. I shall hope my maid has arrived with my trunk.”
You lead her upstairs and show her the room before retreating to your own, thankful that the Gardiners have enough spare rooms that you do not have to share with Miss Darcy. Much as you like the girl, it would be uncomfortable for you both since you just met.
The meal is a quiet one. Aunt Gardiner speaks of the physician’s suggestions, and Colonel Fitzwilliam suggests sending his father’s physician to examine Mr. Darcy as well. You bristle for your uncle at the suggestion that his physician is somehow lacking, but Uncle Gardiner takes it in stride, cheerful agreeing that a second opinion might be valuable.
You do not linger long downstairs after dinner. Miss Darcy goes upstairs to be with her brother, Colonel Fitzwilliam soon following, and you are too exhausted after a long day to stay with your aunt and uncle for long. You fall asleep quickly, although you wake several times from dreams of Mr. Darcy dying en route to London or being in the carriage and covered in his blood.
The next day passes quietly. After breakfast, Colonel Fitzwilliam goes back to his regiment, and Miss Darcy spends much of the morning with her brother. After some time, however, she comes downstairs.
“I appreciate your hospitality,” she says, her eyes flicking from you to Aunt Gardiner, “but I have an important appointment I must keep. I believe my cousin brought my brother’s carriage here?”
“Yes, it is at your disposal,” Aunt Gardiner assures her. “But you are not going out alone, surely! Would you like Elizabeth to accompany you?”
“Oh, no, I would not trouble her for such a little thing,” Miss Darcy says, but you notice that her eyes slide away from your aunt. “My maid will come with me, and I will return in a few hours. My brother is sleeping, so I know I can safely leave him in your care.”
“My dear, I believe we should speak with your brother first. I cannot in good conscience let a young lady of fifteen go out into London with only a maid for escort.”
Miss Darcy looks up, her eyes showing a startling amount of fire for the quiet girl. “Not even to see her own aunt? Mrs. Gardiner, I mean no offense, but it is not your place to question me.” She stalks off, and you and your aunt exchange a look.
She is right, though. Neither Aunt Gardiner nor you have the right to stop the girl from doing as she pleases, as you are not her guardians or even related to her. Mr. Darcy is sleeping, and by the time he could be wakened, the girl will be long gone. Surely she is safe enough traveling to her aunt’s house—this is Colonel Fitzwilliam’s mother, is she not?—although perhaps you might ask if the aunt could send a carriage to retrieve her next time.
You find yourself pondering over Miss Darcy’s words and attitude. She is very eager to go out without anyone else, except a maid, and she did not bring her companion to Gracechurch Street. She is generally quieter and better-behaved, but you have a vast deal of experience with younger sisters, and Miss Darcy’s mulish determination to go out reminds you of Lydia.
Still, the Darcys are none of your business, aside from what is necessary for Mr. Darcy to recuperate under the Gardiners’ roof. He will be in his room upstairs for a few days and then depart. You have no reason to concern yourself with any of their affairs.
In the afternoon, you walk to the park again with Miss Hammerlin and your cousins, although this time, you do not see anyone you know.
After you return to the house and hand the children over to their mother and governess, you find Mr. Darcy alone in the drawing room.
“Georgiana?” he asks, looking past you.
“She is still out?” you ask, taking up the book that you had left on a side table.
“She was not with you?” He looks bemused. “Your aunt mentioned that you had both gone out.”
“Oh! No, she went out earlier in your carriage to an appointment of some sort. I went with the children to the park.” You watch him, curious what he knows of Miss Darcy’s appointment.
“Appointment?” He stands up quickly, and a pained look comes across his face. He puts his hand to the back of his head. “What appointment?”
“To her aunt’s, I believe she said. Is that Colonel Fitzwilliam’s mother?”
“Oh. Of course. She went out with Colonel Fitzwilliam.” He lowers himself back into his chair, his hand still to his head.
“I am afraid not. He went to his regiment today. My aunt did try to dissuade Miss Darcy from going out alone with only a maid, but she was . . . determined. And we had no authority to stop her.”
Mr. Darcy’s face darkens. “I have that authority. You could have wakened me!”
“By which time she would have been long gone, as we could not physically restrain her, and the carriage is your own and thus hers to command.”
With a huff of air, Mr. Darcy says, “At least she has only gone to my aunt’s home. Lady Matlock is beginning to introduce Georgiana to important acquaintances in preparation for her coming out, although I would have preferred Georgiana have her companion accompany her. I suppose there is no room for her?”
“I believe we have taken all of my aunt and uncle’s spare rooms,” Elizabeth admitted. “Someone would have to share.”
“Ah.” He frowns. “Nonetheless, I cannot like her going out alone. She was supposed to be safe here. I will speak with her when she returns.”
You look at the book in your lap, then back at Mr. Darcy. You held off on your curiosity for an entire day, but it seems impossible to wait another moment now that you are alone. You will have no better opportunity.
“Mr. Darcy, what happened to you yesterday? Why were you on the road? And why were you so anxious to get to London?”
You have read in books of a person’s face becoming “closed off,” but you have never seen it before this moment.
He is silent for so long that you are sure he will tell you that it is none of your business. “I cannot tell you exactly,” he says. “I was set upon by two men, although they did not say why.”
“Were you on the way to London?”
“I was still at Netherfield.”
Your blood runs cold. You always assumed that he was on the road when he was injured. “You were injured on Netherfield property? You were in riding gear; we assumed you had been riding to London.”
“I had been riding, but on Bingley’s property.”
“Is that why you did not want to return to Netherfield Park?”
“It was part of it. I was also anxious to get to my sister.”
“Were you concerned she would be worried for you?”
His eyes are distant, unfocused. “Yes, and . . . well, yes.” It is not a complete answer, but he does not elaborate.
“Have you written to warn Mr. Bingley?”
Mr. Darcy’s attention turns back to you. “Warn Mr. Bingley?”
“Of the danger! You would not leave him unprotected when there are dangerous men attacking people on his lands.”
There is something odd about this. Mr. Darcy’s response is too slow. Because of his head injury? Or is there another reason? “Of course,” he says slowly.
Maybe there is a reason Mr. Darcy does not seem worried for Mr. Bingley’s safety. Maybe Mr. Darcy knows that he, and he alone, was the target.
It would make sense. He is wealthier than Mr. Bingley, and from what Mr. Collins said, he has wealthy and titled relatives. He could be ransomed for more than Mr. Hurst or Mr. Bingley. But no, kidnap for ransom does not make sense. Mr. Darcy was found injured far from where he was attacked. That meant that either ransom is not their design, or that he somehow escaped his kidnappers.
“You will warn Mr. Bingley?”
“I will tell him what he needs to know.”
He is certainly holding something back. He would not assume Mr. Bingley is safe from the danger unless he somehow knows for certain he is the target. Even if that is the case, why is he not anxious to assure his friend of his safety? If he was attacked on a ride, they must be worried for him at Netherfield!
Unless he suspects that someone from Netherfield Park is involved, or maybe wants to keep his survival a secret. But why? Is there something more nefarious about Mr. Darcy than any of you suspect?
You need information, and you need to know what is going on back in Meryton. Is Mr. Darcy even telling the truth about the attack?
Should you
confront Mr. Darcy with your suspicions and ask him for the truth about why he was attacked
or
write to Charlotte Lucas asking what people were saying and what is happening at Netherfield?

Cast your vote in the comments below! I am going to take a week’s break as I am working on an audio release and need to get some writing done, but I will have the next part for you in two weeks.
36 comments
Skip to comment form
Write to Charlotte Lucas – Elizabeth already knows Darcy is holding something back. I don’t think asking Darcy will tell her anything more.
Ask for the truth.
I don’t think Mr. Darcy would react well to being confronted. I would write to Charlotte to find out what she has heard.
Write to Charlotte, Darcy is not going to share anymore unless Georgiana doesn’t come back.
I think Lizzie would question Mr Darcy
I agree as above, write to Charlotte to hear what is being said at home, he obviously doesn’t want to confide in Elisabeth.
Confront Mr Darcy – is her family in danger for housing /helping Mr Darcy? Elizabeth would want to know.
Elizabeth should do both! She should also tell Darcy about seeing Wickham! It seems obvious that Georgiana’s appointment was with him so they need Colonel Fitzwilliam to hunt her down. She must know her brother wouldn’t approve and she is obviously more concerned with meeting him than tending to her injured brother. Maybe Georgiana should ask herself who would benefit from injuring Darcy? (Sorry, I’m getting ahead of myself!) 🫢😳
I’m with Glynis. Both! Along with all of the other things she listed.
Plan to write to Charlotte, Mr Darcy is not going to reveal the whole truth even if Elizabeth continues to question him. And it will be good to know another perspective especially since we suspect Mr Bennet sent Lizzie away for another reason besides what he stated at the beginning.
Elizabeth should definitely write to Charlotte, as she would tell her exactly what is going on in Meryton
He has already denied her information so writing to Charlotte is my vote. Though I think it is more in character for her to confront him for answers.
She should write to Charlotte to ask what reason has been given for Darcy’s sudden departure, although business in London or Pemberley would be the obvious excuses. If they are worried about his disappearance then surely by now the servants would have let slip that Bingley is very concerned about his friend. Jane might have opportunities to investigate the residents of Netherfield but might be less inclined to suspect them of being involved in Darcy’s injuries than Charlotte would be.
Press Mr Darcy for more information!
I want Elizabeth to confront Mr Darcy but writing to Charlotte might get Elizabeth more answers.
confront Mr. Darcy
E should write to Charlotte.
Confront Mr. Darcy now since she may not have time alone with him again soon. I think E will also end up writing to Charlotte, trying to gain as much inside knowledge as possible for this mystery.
Oh definitely write to Charlotte. Darcy won’t tell a thing!! And you need to know!!
I think she should press him for more information! Ask if her family is in danger for housing him. And then tell him she met Wickham in the park and he asked about Mr. Darcy but she didn’t say anything.
Confront him. It is the best way to keep your loved ones safe.
Insist Darcy give you the truth, both to protect the Gardiners and the Bennet family if there is a villain in Meryton. E could also write to Charlotte, but all Charlotte would know is the gossip–which can contain truths, but would not be the entire story. Further, E should tell Darcy about meeting his old friend in the park.
My vote is both but not entirely. Tell Mr. Darcy about concern for Georgiana since she has been gone for some time, that you fear she is concealing her actual reason for departure. Also write to Charlotte to get latest from Meryton and mention that you had seen Wickham in London without mentioning Darcy at all.
I think she should confront Mr. Darcy while she has the chance. She can then write to Charlotte to see what is being said in Meryton.
Confront Mr Darcy and describe how Georgiana was when she left.
Ask Mr. Darcy
While a letter to Charlotte is safer…the situation makes me feel that time is of the essence, and even though it is about a 4 hour distance, there’s no guarantee that you would get a response quick enough .
I hope Georgiana didn’t run off with Wickham…
I would first ask Mr. Darcy up front about what is going on, and then I would also write Charlotte Lucas and ask her what is being said at home in Meryton and compare the answers–so I would do both. The more information I can gather, the better I will be able to help.
Confront.
Write Charlotte! She will know more, and then Elizabeth can confront Darcy. I think, if she has more info, he’ll be more likely to share info with her. Thanks, Sarah!
Confront Mr. Darcy with your suspicions and ask him for the truth about why he was attacked
I think she would do both, actually. She would want to see how different the news is from what he might say.
Confront Mr Darcy. I think we all know who Georgiana went to meet. Darcy and Elizabeth can save her.
Write to Charlotte Lucas, and while you’re at it, find Georgiana and make sure she isn’t into trouble.
I’d confront Mr. Darcy and then write to Charlotte to compare both stories.
Ask Darcy for the truth. It isn’t likely that Charlotte would know any specifics about the inhabits of Netherfield. I still think it was a mistake for Elizabeth to speak of Wickham to Georgiana. 🙂
Can’t Elizabeth do both. A general letter to a friend giving her news and asking about news from Meryton and surrounding areas.
At the same time gently probing Darcy about the assault.
I’m more worried about Georgiana. Where is she? Why? What is she doing?