Thanks for joining me on our Create Your Own JAFF Adventure! Just starting? You can catch up on previous posts collected here: https://austenvariations.com/category/sarah-courtney/ . Last week, the injured Mr. Darcy, currently safe in the care of the Gardiners’, asked for his sister. Readers voted that Elizabeth should go herself to fetch Georgiana, so this week’s story will start there.
If you’d prefer the third person version, you can read it here. There’s a link at the bottom of the intro part that will jump you to the newest part. Just don’t forget to come back and comment to tell me what Elizabeth should do next!

You approach the door at the address Mr. Darcy provided and smile confidently at your companion. Miss Hammerlin, the governess for the Gardiners’ children, is anxious about the etiquette of approaching the house without being acquainted with Miss Darcy. In other circumstances, you would share her hesitation. But Mr. Darcy is concerned for his sister, and his sister ought to know that her brother is injured and at the Gardiners’ house. For all you know, Miss Darcy may be expecting him to arrive at any moment.
At your knock, a butler appears in the doorway. Tall and slightly stooped, he somehow still conveys the impression of a man with his nose elevated almost as much as Caroline Bingley’s.
“I am afraid, madam, that the family is not at home.”
Before he can close the door, you blurt, “But Mr. Darcy is injured at my aunt’s house, and he has sent me to bring Miss Darcy to him.”
The butler’s bushy eyebrows rise a notch. “Neither Mr. nor Miss Darcy is currently available, madam. Good day.”
Before he can make another attempt to close the door, you thrust a card at him. “Please, take this. It is the location where Mr. Darcy is recovering. Even if you do not believe me, you must at least tell Miss Darcy where her brother is.”
The butler takes the card as if it is some sort of dung beetle you shoved into his hand, but at least he took it. A moment later, the door shuts in your faces.
“Unfortunate,” Miss Hammerlin murmurs. “I do understand, of course. He must be protective of his mistress, and our story is a bit odd. But Miss Darcy must be told.”
“Perhaps I should have sent a note after all,” you muse. “But would she not be likely to ignore that? Do you think she is really away from home, or not at home to us?”
“It makes little difference in the end,” Miss Hammerlin says.
“I suppose.” You hate to return to Mr. Darcy and tell him you failed. Is he the sort of man to grow angry? He must have other relatives who are more likely to act on the information. Wait, did Mr. Collins not mention that Mr. Darcy is the nephew of his patroness, Lady Catherine de Bourgh? She lives in Kent, though, not London. Perhaps Uncle Gardiner can write to her by express. She may be able to be in London by tomorrow if he sends it soon.
“We will have to return to the house for now,” you tell Miss Hammerlin. “Mr. Gardiner may have returned at my aunt’s summons, and he may have better luck in sending a note to Miss Darcy, or Mr. Darcy may have another relative we might notify.”
Your return to the house is subdued. Aunt Gardiner greets you at the door, peering behind Miss Hammerlin. “She did not come with you?”
You shake your head. “She was not at home.”
“Disappointing, but not shocking.” Aunt Gardiner shakes her head. “We will have to tell Mr. Darcy immediately. I convinced him to rest, but he is anxious for his sister and cannot be at peace.” She smiles at Miss Hammerlin. “Thank you for your assistance.”
“Of course, madam.” Miss Hammerlin curtsies before hurrying upstairs to her charges.
When you reach Mr. Darcy’s sitting room, Aunt Gardiner knocks. The door is opened by a footman Aunt Gardiner set to keep an eye on her guest.
As you enter, Mr. Darcy, who was resting on a comfortable chair with his eyes closed, wakes with a jerk.
“Miss Bennet!” He sits up straight. “My sister?” Just as Aunt Gardiner did at the door, his eyes strays past you, looking for Miss Darcy.
“I am afraid that she was not at home,” you say. “Have you any other relative we might summon?”
“Not at home?” he repeats. Pushing against the armrests, he rises to his feet, wobbling alarmingly. “Where is she?”
“Mr. Darcy!” Aunt Gardiner exclaims, rushing to his side. The footman hurries to support him from the other. “We are doing our best to fetch her for you, but you must sit down! Heaven help us if you should collapse.”
“It would take a great number of footmen to get you back up,” you quip, regretting it instantly when his eyes flicked back to yours. What must he think of your teasing when he is in pain? “I am not certain if she was truly away from home or if she was not at home to us. We are strangers, after all, bearing odd tales about you.”
Mr. Darcy nods and then winces, holding his head. He slowly lowers himself back into the chair.
“Of course. I should have thought of that, but I was not thinking straight. My cousin, Colonel Fitzwilliam, is stationed at the barracks. If I may have a pen and ink, I will write a note that will convince him to find Georgiana. I should have done so from the start.”
Aunt Gardiner promptly supplies him with paper and writing implements and the letter is duly written. Once it is, and dispensed with a footman with careful instructions, she becomes stern.
“Mr. Darcy, your cousin will receive the message and retrieve your sister. However, it will all take some time, and you are recovering from having your brain considerably jolted. Mr. Bartley insisted that you must rest as much as possible. I insist that you remove to your bedchamber and lie down, even if you cannot sleep. Your sister will be here as soon as she may be, and you may be assured that I will inform you as soon as she and your cousin arrive.”
Mr. Darcy meekly concedes, to your surprise. Given his arrogance in Meryton, you would never have imagined he would take orders from a tradesman’s wife, but his injuries must leave him more compliant than he would ordinarily be.
Once you are back downstairs, Aunt Gardiner has another request.
“Lizzy, would you go with Miss Hammerlin to the park? I would usually accompany her, since the children can be a handful once they see the ducks, but I really think I ought to remain here to greet Mr. Darcy’s cousin and his sister if they should arrive sooner than expected and, of course, in case Mr. Darcy has need of something.”
You nod slowly. You don’t like to leave while Mr. Darcy is in such a state, but truly, what is he to you? A gentleman you do not even like with whom you have a trifling acquaintance. Not only have you imposed on Aunt Gardiner without prior invitation, but you have brought along trouble to her household. The least you can do is to help with the children.
“I would be happy to.”
The children are bundled into warm clothing with the expertise of a governess who is very accustomed to frequent trips to the park. Perhaps a little too bundled, according to the children’s protests, as the day is not very cold considering the season. Soon enough, you are hurrying to the park, you trotting ahead with the older ones while Miss Hammerlin tries to keep up while dragging little Michael, whose legs are shorter than those of his siblings and who is all too prone to being distracted by an interesting leaf or animal dropping.
A breeze makes you shiver, and you remember that Mr. Darcy spent the morning lying on the ground before the coachman found him. How lucky he is that it was not raining and that it is not as cold as Novembers typically were.
You worried a little that your cousins would scatter in four different directions upon arrival at the park, but thankfully they find a game they can all play together. Margaret and Cecilia almost immediately find friends to play with, reluctantly including Andrew in a game of chase. Michael eagerly runs after them, pumping his little legs in an attempt to keep up and almost toppling over every time he changes directions.
A group of men walking by on the path catches your eye, and you study them as they pass. Wait, you know that man . . .
Just as you recognise him, he looks up and catches your gaze. His face breaks into a grin, and he says something briefly to his companions before breaking off from the group.
“Miss Bennet!” he greets you jovially. “I am surprised to see you in London!”
“A pleasure to see you, Mr. Wickham.” After curtsying, you gesture to the children and Miss Hammerlin, who stands a little distance away. “I have come to London to visit my aunt and uncle.”
“I had not know you planned to visit. When last we spoke, you talked of the ball at Netherfield Park.”
“The ball was last night, and it was a delight. My father sent me to London today.” You almost say, “After an awkward proposal from Mr. Collins,” but Mr. Collins, irritating as he is, does not deserve to have his rejected proposal made public outside her family.
“Today!” Mr. Wickham’s eyes light up. “I am especially pleased to meet you, then, as I have been in London these past several days. What news do you have from Hertfordshire?”
For once, you can understand why Lydia takes such delight in being the first to find out every tidbit of news. Mr. Wickham will be shocked to hear of Mr. Darcy’s appearance on the road. While Mr. Wickham is too kind to take delight in another’s injuries, he must feel at least a little vindicated by his enemy’s misfortune.
“Mr. Darcy . . .” you begin, but then you stop.
Although Mr. Wickham is a good and honest man, you cannot deny he was a little indiscreet in the past, to tell you so much of his history with Mr. Darcy so quickly, although of course that was his own story to tell, not gossip. If you swear him to secrecy, will Mr. Wickham keep the news of Mr. Darcy’s situation to himself?
“Mr. Darcy?” Mr. Wickham asks, eyebrows raised. “What of him?”
He is expecting something surprising about Mr. Darcy now. But what should you tell him?
Should you:
tell him that your coachman found Mr. Darcy on the road and brought him to the Gardiners’,
or
tell him that Mr. Darcy asked you to dance at the Netherfield Ball?
56 comments
Skip to comment form
Oh I feel Darcy bei g injured should not be broadcasted. Lizzy should say that she was asked to dance.
Oooh clever way to deny us (and Elizabeth!) an early glimpse of Georgiana. I vote dancing.
Also, in the email newsletter, it says the link for the 3rd person POV will have a link at the bottom to jump to the latest chapter, but I’m not seeing that. I have to tap on every outcome. This is on an Android phone using Chrome. It’s not a huge deal but sharing in case that’s something you want fixed.
Loving this story so far!!
Oh I feel Darcy being injured should not be broadcasted. Lizzy should say that she was asked to dance.
Obviously, Elizabeth as a perceptive lady should not say anything about Darcy’s injuries and location. Talking about Darcy and dancing would be a better idea.
Asked you to dance!
Definitely do not tell him what happened to Mr. Darcy, or where he is. You can tell him that Mr. Darcy asked to dance wit you.
To be honest, I would say “He (Mr. Darcy) was his usual self at the Netherfield Ball…(and etc.)”. I don’t think it would be wise to say anything much about him.
However, of the choices…that you/Lizzy danced with him.
I really wonder if Georgianna is in Town. With a hit to his head, maybe Mr. Darcy is thinking/worrying about something that has already happened.
Tell him that Mr. Darcy asked you to dance at the ball.
Elizabeth needs to be rather cautious with Wickham. If Lydia is so enthusiastic about Wickham and he pays attention to one so young, Elizabeth should wonder why W pays Lydia so much attention and flattery.
dance
Of course none of us trust Wickham an inch. But Elizabeth doesn’t know what we know. Perhaps it would be natural for her to enlist his help.
Elizabeth you don’t trust Mr Wickham so tell him Mr Darcy asked you to dance. Say it was an enjoyable experience. He’s a very good dancer. You had a lovely time.
Ask him what’s he doing in London. Is he with the regiment. Gently probe for his plans to see if he knows anything about Georgiana or the Bingley’s whereabouts.
At this point in the story, Wickham is the most amiable man of Lizzie’s acquaintance, she has little reason to suspect the news of Darcy’s injury and whereabouts will mean much to him at all. He has been indiscreet about personal matters however and this is entirely gossip, so perhaps she should comment on the dance. I can’t decide!
For goodness sake don’t tell him about Darcy being injured or where he is 😱 just say he asked you to dance. Then claim the children need you and walk away! Or you could ask him how come he’s spent several days in London when he’s supposed to be in the militia in Meryton? 🤔
Tell WIckham you danced with Darcy at the ball
Neither LOL. The last thing Wickham needs to know is that Darcy is injured and vulnerable leaving Georgiana defenseless. And she herself has no one to help her if he decides to drag her off now that he knows Darcy is seriously interested in her.
Oof! This is a tough one — not because I don’t know the answer I want her to give (dance, or some trivial comment, not the truth of Darcy’s injuries) but because I’m not sure what Elizabeth, at this point in her story arc, would do. Still, I’ll go with “dance” (or some other trivial comment about Darcy). She at least realizes she’d be gossiping if she shared the injury news with Wickham, and I think she can restrain herself from being so much like Lydia in this moment. She should play it off as a joking comment, and perhaps Mr. Wickham’s response will end up giving her some better understanding of his true character?
Thanks for another intriguing installment!
Asked to dance.
I feel that Wickham is somehow involved with Darcy’s injuries and his location shouldn’t be shared.
Mr Darcy asked her to dance.
Wickham is a scoundrel and will use the information to his own advantage, perhaps even renewing his pursuit of Georgiana. While he shouldn’t know the situation it will be much more interesting a story if he does.
Tell him that he asked you to dance! Maybe for whatever reason, Elizabeth suddenly feels he is untrustworthy?
You should most certainly NOT tell him that Mr. Darcy is injured; a simple sentence about dancing with him at the ball will suffice.
Dancing only!
You pause, inwardly curse your thoughtless tongue for letting Mr. Darcy’s name slip out before thinking, then tell Mr. Wickham that Mr Darcy asked you to dance last evening.
Tell Wickham that Darcy asked you to dance! Trust your instincts!
Tell Wickham that Mr. Darcy asked Elizabeth for a dance.
The dance. This is what Lydia would say. Wickham needs to think Elizabeth is a little frivolous.
Elizabeth should only tell him Mr Darcy asked her to dance and perhaps some other trivial things about the ball.
Neither. I like Jessica’s idea of saying Darcy was his usual self and danced only two dances, without saying who he danced with. Or something else that makes it sound like she is still in agreement with Wickham but without giving anything away about the real situation. If that isn’t an option for the story, then “danced with her”.
Listen to your inner voice, Elizabeth, tell Wickham that Darcy asked you to dance!
In my opinion, even though Elizabeth currently trusts Mr. Whickham and thinks he’s amiable, she would decide against revealing too much about Mr. Darcy’s private affairs, because it wouldn’t be fair to share these things with a man that clearly dislikes him.
So she would only talk about the dance.
In Post 3, Darcy tells Elizabeth he knew he could trust her. Hopefully she still remembers that and doesn’t disclose Darcy’s misfortune to a man who dislikes him and has already told exposed uncomplimentary stories about him. Telling Wickham that Darcy asked her to dance to big enough news.
Danced at the Ball
definitely the dance
Dance or some other white lie.
I tell him that Mr. Darcy asked me to dance at the Netherfield ball. Something inside me tells me to be discreet about Mr. Darcy’s welfare and whereabouts. I have already realized that Wickham is a gossip. He does not need to know about business that is not his own.
I am not sure I trust him entirely so I laugh (a good Lizzy trait) and say he asked me to dance! What does he think about that.
Elizabeth definitely should not tell Wickham anything! For all we know, Wickham may be responsible for Darcy being on the road in the first place.
Of course you can never tell Wickham about Darcy!
Do not tell Wickham about finding Darcy, just mention that he asked Elizabeth to dance.
I suspect Wickham was involved in the attack on Darcy, and is out to get Georgiana
Dance. Don’t tell Wickham anything important!
I suggest DANCE.
Wickham gossips just as much as Mrs. Philips. Err on the side of caution…the dance.
This I one is a conundrum. If you tell him more, it amps up the conflict. If you don’t, you keep the status quo.
Lizzy would give a little info but not all. Like saying they danced, and Mr Darcy said he was leaving for London.
Dance. Please don’t give Wickham fuel. He isn’t to be trusted, Elizabeth.
I’m so enjoying this story! I don’t think Lizzy should tell Wickham. She should just say they danced.
Tell him that Mr. Darcy asked you to dance at the Netherfield Ball.
Darcy invited you to dance, Wickham is not to be trusted!
Asked to dance. Also, wasn’t Elizabeth expecting to dance with Wickham at the dance? A little righteous indignation is warranted?
I agree with everyone else – give away as little information as possible, Mr Wickham is a gossip and Mr Darcy said he trusts Elizabeth
I feel like Lizzy would mentally recoil when she realizes she just compared herself to Lydia, and that would bring her to mention dancing with Darcy instead of him being injured. Taking into account the history between the two gentlemen, as well, I think would lead her to be more discreet.
Tell Wickham only about the dance
Nobody seems worried about letting on to Mr. Wickham that Mr. Darcy may have an interest in Elizabeth, eh? So be it! Next week, Elizabeth will tell Mr. Wickham that she danced with Mr. Darcy (and keep Mr. Darcy’s injuries a secret for now).
I am going to take a week off, as it’s been a real challenge to keep up with this as well as my other writing and editing, and because it’s a holiday weekend. The next part will post the following Saturday, April 11th. Thanks for reading!
I thought she shouldn’t let him know Darcy asked her to dance but that was the better of the two options given! Ideally as she’s already mentioned him she should maybe just say Darcy was as proud as ever at the Ball then ask why he wasn’t there after saying he wouldn’t let Darcy drive him away!
Have a lovely Easter 🐣
I was thinking she would tell Wickham about dancing to make him jealous since she had expected to dance with Wickham at the ball.
Darcy asked you to dance.
I’m loving the story!
I am the suspicious sort. I would not tell him bout Darcy’s injury.