It’s Halloween tomorrow, so I’m guessing you’ve already carved the pumpkins and stocked up for Trick or Treat. If you’re anything like me, that stash must be awfully tempting, so let me entice you to sneak away with a chocolate bar and think with some compassion of our Regency forebears, who had never tasted such delights because chocolate as we know it had yet to be invented.
I hope your compassion will extend to a certain gentleman, even if he can’t seem to coin a marriage proposal in a gentlemanlike manner to save his life. In my opinion, one of the greatest achievements of the 1995 adaptation of Pride and Prejudice was Mr Darcy’s utterly abysmal first proposal. Jane Austen never gave us his exact words, but with great skill Andrew Davies filled in the blanks and made Mr Darcy bury himself and blast his chances in one minute flat (58 secs, to be precise, from ‘In vain I have struggled, it will not do…’ to ‘… I beg you most fervently to relieve my suffering and consent to be my wife.’). Please time it if you like, or just enjoy the cringe-worthy moment (if ‘enjoy’ is the right word for it 😉 ). So, let Mr Darcy suffer the indignity of a click on his manly nose (just kidding, you can click anywhere on this picture) and we’ll hear him have his say:
I will admit I watch this often and even if I know how that awful first proposal goes, I still can’t help thinking, ‘For goodness’ sake, if only something would stop him before he makes a complete fool of himself!!’
Funnily enough, that was how my latest book came to be: it all spun from the ‘If only something would stop him!’
Are you sitting comfortably, with or without a Trick or Treat choc bar? I hope so, and I hope you’ll let me entertain you with a ghost story (what better time for it than at Halloween?)
The setting is not Halloween-y. Our dear characters are not taking refuge in a deserted mansion. Instead, they’re sitting on a secluded bench, it’s April not October, and Mr Darcy is just about to deliver something along the lines of his original first proposal. And, just like in the novel we all love, he’s making a dreadful mess of it – until, in the timeless spirit of Halloween, he gets to commune with the departed in ways he would never have expected:
* * * * *
Excerpt from The Darcy Legacy
(Beware, there be ghosts! And spoilers 😉 )
It was rather fortunate that she had already noticed his approach, sparing him the task of finding some other way of making his presence known, so as not to startle her. Thus, he could simply say, “Good morning,” – although it was drawing closer to midday – and civilly follow it with “May I join you?”
Her full attention now back on her sketch, Elizabeth briefly tightened her lips – in concentration on her task, or displeasure at his question? – before she said, as she traced a few bold lines, “Pray do. Unless you came to find fault with my perspective and my grasp of detail.”
The customary mixture of sweetness and archness in her manner made it as difficult as ever to tell if she was teasing him or she was in earnest, but Darcy availed himself of the free seat on the bench nevertheless.
She paid him little heed, her eyes darting up and down between the scenery ahead and her open sketchbook. The landscape she had chosen for a model was already recognisable, slowly taking shape on the white paper. Darcy refrained from steadfastly keeping his eyes on her handiwork so as not to disconcert her and, after a brief inspection, he leaned back against the tree trunk, his gaze ahead. He remained thus when he began speaking.
“I will endeavour to comply. But ‘tis somewhat of a hardship.”
“What is?”
“Not commenting on your perspective.”
This time she did turn to face him, a brow arched.
“I see. Very well. Have your say, if you must. What offends you? The shape of the birch? The reeds? The lake? Or the overall angle?”
“I was not speaking of your sketch. No one could find anything wanting, nor dispute your skill with the charcoal. What I had in mind was your general perspective.”
“You will have to do a little better than pithy remarks, sir.”
“I was hoping to. What I meant to ask is why would you assume I came to find fault? Can you not imagine I came to find you because I simply could not stay away?”
Her eyes widened. Despite himself, Darcy gave a little rueful chuckle.
“Forgive me. That was blunt,” he said softly, reaching to gather her small hand in his, the charcoal still poised between her fingers. He drew it from her slacking grasp with his free hand, lest it mar the artwork, and set it on the bench between them as he stroked the back of her fingers with his thumb. “I would have liked to court you as you deserve to be courted, before blurting out that I was bewitched within days – hours – of making your acquaintance. I should have said so – long ago. I wish I had. So much time lost. Besides, courting you now, at Rosings, has its… difficulties,” he felt compelled to clarify, although he was convinced that by then she knew enough of Lady Catherine and her ways to make any further clarifications needless. Still, he pensively continued, “Your change of circumstances should have made everything easier, and in the main it does, but at the moment it complicates matters too. In many ways, it would have been preferable if you had remained the second daughter of a gentleman of little consequence in Hertfordshire.”
Her hand twitched in his, and her chin came up.
“I am still the daughter of a gentleman of little consequence from Hertfordshire, sir.”
“I beg your pardon, that was badly put. What I meant,” he said, struggling for better words, “is that I should have courted you then. There was a wealth of opportunity and a great deal more freedom. My sole excuse – and a poor one at that – is that your connections rather served as a deterrent. Needless to say, I should have known better. Their condition in life may be far beneath my own, but they made you who you are, and you are flawless, so whatever they did must have been right. As for their want of propriety – aye, that could be mortifying, and it often was, but the same can be said of my aunt. If anything, Lady Catherine’s shortcomings are far less excusable. Noblesse oblige, and an earl’s daughter should know a vast deal more about ladylike deportment than an attorney’s wife,” he said with energy, glad that his words were coming with greater ease, now that his case was taking shape and he could explain his standpoint better. Yet, just as he had begun to feel less tongue-tied, the flow of his discourse was abruptly interrupted by an exclamation coming out of nowhere:
“Heaven help us, what is the lad about?”
Darcy started and instinctively turned to look over his shoulder for the source of the irate remark. Yet he saw no one. And the voice gave him pause. Had he not known better, he would have said it sounded like… Well, a little like his father. He glanced around again, not in the least amused by the prospect of anyone interrupting his proposal. It was equally unamusing to suspect that he had started hearing things. Nevertheless, after all the galling interruptions – particularly on the previous day – he was glad to note that no one was there. He straightened in his seat and turned back towards Elizabeth, to see profound displeasure in her most expressive countenance. He suppressed a smile. So she was not fond of interruptions either.
“What I wished to say,” Darcy resumed, “is that I have wasted too many opportunities already. I will not waste any more time on my aunt’s account. Little as the result will please her, she has raised your consequence, and you will be more readily accepted in society as Lady Catherine’s relation than as an unknown young lady from three miles north of Meryton.”
“‘Struth! Was I expected to teach him how to go about it? He is a grown man of eight-and-twenty – has lived in the world – spoken to people – read books. There are more than enough in the library. How can he make such a cursed hash of it? He pines for the lass for months on end and now he sits there, insults her and calls it a proposal!”
This time Darcy released Elizabeth’s hand, sprang to his feet and looked around in earnest. Whoever said that would pay for his impertinence. Eavesdropping was bad enough, but mocking him – in his hearing – and at a time like this! Who was it? They knew him well – too well. Well enough to know about the months of pining. Surely it was not one of Fitzwilliam’s jests! That was beyond the pale, even for him. And there was naught amiss with his proposal – not that it was anyone’s affair but his. He was going about it in the proper manner. As for insulting her, he had just complimented her, for goodness’ sake, and declared that her eminently vulgar aunt was nowhere near as much at fault as Lady Catherine. How was that insulting? And, more to the point, how dared he, whoever the impudent wretch was?
“Who goes there?” he called, and looked up too, for good measure. No one in the tree, risking life and limb. And the voice was a mature one, not that of a child. And still uncannily like his father’s.
“What the deuce is he doing now? Who is he looking for?”
Darcy spun around towards his companion.
“Elizabeth, could you ascertain where that came from?”
She cast him a severe glance and picked up her charcoal from where he had left it, on the bench.
“There are a great many things that I fail to ascertain right now,” she said crisply, “not least your reasons for this strange performance. Pray amuse yourself at leisure, if you must, but kindly step out of the way. I would like to get back to my sketch.”
“And now he has vexed her. Lord help me! How difficult can it be? If he will have that lass and none other, must he antagonise her so? I will not see my line wiped out from the face of the earth, by Jove! Get your wits about you, Son! Just tell her you love her,” the voice in his head forcefully commanded.
“Son? What insolence is this? Enough, I say!” Darcy exclaimed, turning on his heel to cast a fierce look around.
For a moment, there was naught but silence. He could only hear the faint rustling of the wind through the yellowed reeds. Even the twittering birds seemed to have been hushed by his outburst.
“For a moment, there was naught but silence. He could only hear the faint rustling of the wind through the yellowed reeds. Even the twittering birds seemed to have been hushed by his outburst. “
And then a shocked whisper filled his head.
“Fitzwilliam? Son, you can hear me?”
He spun around again, his eyes darting searchingly this way and that.
“What is the meaning of this? Where are you? Who are you?”
The ensuing silence lasted for a mere fraction of a second. Then a torrent of words came.
“He heard me! Aye. Truly, he did. Who knows? I cannot say. For the life of me, I cannot fathom how I could hear him from hundreds of miles – not just his words, but whatever is going on in his head. And he heard me, too. No, of course he is not asleep. He was talking to the lass, making a hash of it. He must be wide-awake, yet he could hear me nonetheless. Fitzwilliam? Can you hear me still? By all that is holy, I swear he could hear me a moment ago, Anne!”
“Mr Darcy? Are you well?” Elizabeth added her voice to the cacophony.
Stunned by everything else that he was hearing, he could only whisper, “Anne?”
“No, sir. ‘Tis Elizabeth. You should sit. You seem to be unwell,” Elizabeth urged, but the voice in his head drowned out her advice. It was a great deal louder.
“Yes! You can hear me still. Thank goodness. But what wretched timing, eh? The lass will think you fit for Bedlam. She is in the right, my boy, you had much better sit. This could unhinge anybody. Sit down, Son, and listen—”
“Son?” Darcy repeated, mightily struggling for a grasp on sanity.
“It must be the sun,” Elizabeth agreed. “Another bright morning, I grant you, and warmer than yesterday. Have you been walking over the fields for long? Do sit, Mr Darcy. I fear you might be suffering from sunstroke.”
“Come, now, my boy,” the voice in his head urged as well. “Listen to the lass, sit yourself down and let me do the talking, else she will think you have lost your mind if you keep talking to the trees. Also, I have no notion how long this will hold, the connection, and I must have my say while it does.”
“How is this…? No… impossible,” Darcy whispered as he took their advice and sat, clasping the hand that had somehow made its way into his, as though it were a lifeline.
“I think not,” Elizabeth countered. “‘Tis sunstroke, most likely.”
The voice in his head, however, readily agreed with him:
“Impossible, aye. Anyone would think so.”
It was too confusing for his scattered senses, and for the first time since the beginning of their acquaintance, instead of seeking to pick out Elizabeth’s voice from a crowd as he was wont to do, Darcy endeavoured to dissociate himself from it, so that it would not distract him from the other, which continued:
“Yet here we are. Goodness knows how. The only other time when I could conquer the obvious limitations of my current state was when I was beset by violent emotion. In this case, it must be anger at your bungling that proposal so. By Jove, you will not be the last Darcy of Pemberley, if I can help it. So I will tell you this: if your happiness and the future of my line rests upon this lass, then bestir yourself and make a better job of trying to secure her. Whoever courts his lady by insulting her connections, my boy? Or sits there talking about Catherine, of all people?”
“Catherine,” Darcy echoed numbly.
“No, sir. Not Anne, nor Catherine, nor any of my sisters. Elizabeth,” she slowly and distinctly said her name again, syllable by syllable and with some emphasis, but Darcy made no answer as the voice in his head chuckled.
“Can you not hold your tongue, lad? I did warn you that you should. Seemingly, you need not speak out loud for me to hear you. Now, still yourself and listen. I would rather not miss this chance to say what must be said. Lord knows I missed too many. All those years, when I should have told you— Yes, yes. You are in the right, my dear. Fitzwilliam, I should not entice you to look back. You should look ahead. So go forth, my boy, and know that you do me proud every day. You always have. I could not have left your sister in better hands, and I know Pemberley will flourish in your care. Your mother and I… er… Hm. I thank you. Aye, of course. Of course I can say it, and I shall. A pity I had to die before I learned how, but there we have it. What I wished to say, Fitzwilliam, is that your mother and I love you very, very dearly, and we both hope to remain tethered to this world for long enough to see you and Georgiana happily settled. Now, I trust you will not mind if I tell him— I must. You can see that, can you not? God bless you, my dearest. Fitzwilliam, if this lass – Elizabeth – is your choice, then hasten to secure her. I— We trust your judgement implicitly. And she seems a good sort of girl, bright and spirited. I would have liked to know her better. But I daresay I should be glad to be around for long enough to learn anything at all about the future mother of my grandchildren. So gather your wits together, lad, as I said, and cease rambling about her station in life and whatnot. Just tell her you love her. If you put your mind to it, I daresay you can be trusted to strike the right note between some self-absorbed dunderhead offended by her connections and a lovestruck mooncalf who readily avows he has spent the last five months wasting away for the love of her,” his father said with an affectionate chuckle, and Darcy could not help echoing it, despite the surreal experience of receiving guidance in matters of the heart from his departed father, and the equally surreal novelty of actually laughing with him.
But better late than never.
His father’s voice had a melancholy ring to it when he replied:
“Aye, too true, my boy. I wish… Well, too late now,” he checked himself, his tones suffused with the greatest sadness. “I take comfort in knowing that you will do better than me in every regard. You will make a fine father, and if I am not mistaken, the young lass will bring joy and laughter to my grandchildren’s lives, and yours. By the bye, if you prefer not to play the part of the lovestruck mooncalf when you secure her, once you are married pray do not wait for the afterlife to tell the lass she means the world to you. Believe you me, it will serve you better if you say so – and show it, too – while you are living. And it bears frequent repetition.” (© 2018 by Joana Starnes)
* * * * *
Let’s hope that Mr Darcy follows this very sensible advice. Some of you might know if he does or doesn’t, but if you don’t know what happens next and you’d like to find out, the e-book is still available at half price at Amazon until midnight tomorrow – because it’s Halloween, and to celebrate The Darcy Legacy’s release in Audible, exquisitely narrated by Stevie Zimmerman.
So, if you haven’t read it yet, maybe you’d like to amuse yourselves with it or let Stevie Zimmerman’s beautiful voice bring the story to life. If you’re an Audible.com listener you can find the link here, or please follow this one for Audible UK.
Happy Halloween and thanks for visiting!
26 comments
Skip to comment form
Thanks Joana for this post. Thank you also for this nice offer, I am currently reading The Darcy Legacy in KU. I am enjoying the story and I didn’t notice the timeliness of the P & P variation book I picked. Buying this will help me enjoy the book longer ( I can always go back and keep rereading it) . Thank you again
Good morning, Buturot. So wonderful to hear you’re currently reading The Darcy Legacy and enjoying it! Thank *you* for your kind words and for stopping by to read the post.
I certainly remember this Joana. I love this book. I love the humour, this Darcy, his parents, Elizabeth and Mr Bennet, everything. Thank you so much both for writing it and for sharing this great excerpt 🙂
I’m SO glad you loved The Darcy Legacy, Glynis! I owed Mr B a variation where I don’t kill him off, and really owed you one where I wasn’t torturing Darcy within an inch of his life :)). I remember us chatting about it when we met at Pemberley. What a fun day that was! We should do it again soon. Actually, I think I’ve never seen Pemberley in winter. I wonder if we’ll have any snow this year. I’d love to come up and take some snowy photos to add them to my meagre collection 😉 . And with any luck, I might get snowed in somewhere around there too.
What a lovely teasing chapter from a book which I have not read yet. I am going to download from Amazon now! Thank you for your very generous offer.
So glad you liked the excerpt, Michelle! Hope you’ll like the rest of the book too.
Gosh, that gets me thinking, maybe I should add a spoilers warning. I’ll do that now, just in case 😉
I’ve read the book and yes, it’s a wonderful one for Halloween. We love Mr D anyway for all his imperfections. What’s important is that he through E decides to change even if he never marries her and that makes him our hero. We love him all the more for it. I found your characterizations of Anne Darcy and the elder Mr Darcy not what I expected but plausible given Jane Austen gives us very little about them. Write on!
Wonderful to hear you read The Darcy Legacy and liked it, Meg, thank you! So true, for all Mr Darcy’s imperfections, we do love him, especially because he tries to change his ways because he loves Elizabeth. I’m so glad you found Lady Anne and Mr Darcy the elder plausible, and huge thanks for the encouragement to write on! Best wishes and Happy Halloween!
Wonderful! Thanks Joana!
Thank *you*, Amy, for the fabulous Mysteries of Pemberley! Love all your books and I can’t wait to add this one to my Kindle.
As stated by others above: One of the main reasons I love the P&P story and Mr. Darcy, in particular, is that he is willing to change, even with no promise of a reward, that he takes care of the Lydia situation while wanting no one to mention that he is the “savior” in such. Loved this book and will be listening to it on Audible while I walk. Of course, I do love all your books and thank you for sharing your talent. (Today is my brother’s-in-law birthday.)
I found your portrayal of the communication between “worlds” and even between both Darcy parents very well laid out. High emotion takes charge, indeed.
That’s so beautifully said, Sheila! ‘…that he is willing to change, even with no promise of a reward, that he takes care of the Lydia situation while wanting no one to mention that he is the “savior” in such.’ That’s what I love about Mr Darcy too. I’m so happy you enjoyed The Darcy Legacy and it’s so lovely to think it’ll keep you company on your walks. Thank *you* for your wonderful words about my books and for all your support. Much, much appreciated! Happy Birthday to your brother-in-law and Happy Halloween!
This is one of my very favorite re-imagined P&P proposal scenes, Joana! I just love the spirit of the senior Mr. Darcy interrupting and bringing levity to the situation for the reader.
I’m so happy this is one of your favourite twists on the proposal scene, Debbie! I did have lots of fun imagining it. After writing the angst & the ups and downs in Mr B’s Dutiful Daughter, I really needed to write something light-hearted and tongue-in-cheek, and it was so nice to imagine Mr Darcy having some parental figures guiding him along for a change, more or less gently 😉
Thanks again and have a fun Halloween!
I loved this book. What an excellent excerpt for Halloween. Some are celebrating ‘Trick or Treat’ tonight as we are expecting bad weather on Wednesday. I made a point of NOT opening my bag of candy. I wanted to make sure it didn’t slowly disappear before the kiddos arrived. I just couldn’t trust myself or my husband. In fact, he was the one to suggest that we leave it closed. Smart man. Thanks for the reduced price on this book for those who have not yet purchased it. I wish you the best in its success.
Wonderful to know you loved this book, Jeanne, thanks so much! Oh dear, shame about the bad weather on Wednesday. That’s a smart move, not opening the bag of candy. I can’t trust myself, so I asked my family to hide it well 😀 . I’m happy to report they did a good job of it 😉 . Huge thanks again for the wonderful words and best wishes, you’re ever so kind! Hugs and best wishes back and chat soon.
Joana –
I read The Darcy Legacy about a month or two ago and really loved it. It was a novel approach in so many ways and I devoured the book over one weekend without getting much of anything else done.
I loved getting a glimpse of the senior Darcy’s and their own love story. Needless to say Fitzwilliam really could have used some advice from Darcy Sr. in the original book. He really did make a hash of his proposal to the woman he loved. Lesson learned!
Thanks, Sheila, I’m so happy you read The Darcy Legacy and loved it!
I wonder sometimes how things might have evolved in P&P if Old Mr Darcy were still alive when the son had the rug ripped from under him by the unexpected encounter in Herts 😉 . Would his father have encouraged him to follow his heart, or would Old Mr Darcy still have clung to old prejudices, even with the wisdom of age and experience? I’ve always thought that, of the two, it was Darcy’s father who was more approachable than his mother. The way Darcy described him to Elizabeth has something to do with that (…my parents, who though good themselves, *my father particularly, all that was benevolent and amiable*…). But then he goes on to say they had allowed, encouraged, almost taught him to be selfish, overbearing and proud, so who knows how they would have reacted to a prospective daughter-in-law that had family in trade & no fortune? On the other hand, once they grew older (or in this case, once they passed away), they might come to see that love and purity of heart trump material possessions and empty glitter. I’d like to think that, were he still alive at the time, Old Mr D would have at least allowed, if not encouraged, his son to marry for love.
Ah, this excerpt was a such a lovely memory of that scene. Which I loved. And what happens next!! Woo! I just read this a couple weeks ago and I just sighed when it was finished. I loved the idea of the ‘ghosts.’ Beautiful interactions between them. And soooo funny when another character, and then ANOTHER character, showed up briefly in their midst. It made me grin like the Cheshire Cat. And yet, I took the whole plot at face value, taking it for granted that I was reading one of my rock-star fave authors, enjoying it, angsting through it during ‘the mystery,’ and didn’t make a connection to Halloween. But that is a great tie-in.
Thanks for the excerpt, I hope this entices everyone to go read it. Thanks for writing it. And let me say I am so thrilled it’s available in Audible, oh joy. Puts another huge grin on my face. <3
Thank you, Michelle, I’m SO happy you loved this scene (and the next scene 😉 ), the interactions and all the spirits & people getting in the way. I would’ve loved to see your Cheshire Cat grin :)) . Huge thanks for the wonderful words about my books and for having me down as one of your favourite authors, this means so much to me and it’s such a fabulous encouragement to carry on. So glad you’re thrilled about the Audible version. Stevie Zimmerman is amazing, as always. She put so much emotion in the romantic moments, so much humour in the comical ones, her Darcy is to die for, and OMG her Lady Catherine :D. Thanks ever so much for your support and kind words, and Happy Halloween!
What a lovely ghost story!! (How often do “lovely” and “ghost story” occur in the same sentence?)
It’s a funny scene yet a poignant one as well. I can’t wait to read The Darcy Legacy which I snatched up when the sale started. Thanks!! 🙂
Happy All Hallow’s Eve, Joana and everyone!!
Warmly,
Susanne 🙂
LOL Susanne, come to think of it I haven’t seen ‘lovely’ and ‘ghost story’ in the same sentence very often 😀 . I’m ever so glad you enjoyed this scene, and I hope you’ll like the rest of the book as well. Happy All Hallows’ Eve to you too, and thanks for reading!
All the best,
Joana
This is one of the best stories I have ever read! I have reread it several times and will continue to do so.
Thanks, Lenora!! I’m so happy you liked it so much!!
Your post reminded me that I own this book and have just finished my last book, so I will ignore your excerpt and proceed directly to my Kindle copy. Happy Halloween! I’m sure it will be a treat.
Hi Beatrice, hope you had a happy Halloween too.
That’s a good call, skip the excerpt because there are some spoilers in it 😉
Best wishes and I hope you’ll like the book.