Persuasion 200: The Harvilles and Benwick Share Impressions of Their Visitors

finalcobblogo

The young people from Uppercross travel to Lyme to visit two of Captain Wentworth’s fellow officers. After a pleasant day, Captains Harville and Benwick send the guests off to their inn and sit down for a talk about their friends, new and old.



Captain Harville tamped the tobacco down in his pipe, then lit a spill and attempted to ignite the pipe. His wife came in with two glasses of ale on a small tray, and waved her hand in front of her face to diffuse the acrid smoke.

“Timothy Harville! Must you smoke that foul thing in the house? Your children will be mistaken for factory children when next they go out reeking of smoke!” Her hand on his shoulder diffused the harshness of her words.

Benwick smiled at his hostess, and spoke diffidently. “My dear Mrs. Harville, you are the most tolerant of women, allowing we crude sailors to invade your clean house with our nasty habits.” He smiled, and she saw the moment that he recalled his dead betrothed and the loss of his worldly happiness.

“If we women were not saints the human race would disappear!”

Harville, his pipe finally drawing adequately, spoke up: “I know you do not like my pipe my dear, but I picked up the habit in the West Indies and have not been able to break myself of it. There is not much to do on board when your wife is on shore with the children.” He patted her hand and turned to Benwick. “So James, what do you think of Wentworth’s chances of giving up his bachelorhood? The two Musgrove ladies both seem to find him acceptable, don’t you think?”

Benwick thought for a moment, then spoke meditatively, “Perhaps. Miss Louisa certainly seemed to be trying to attach herself to our friend…I must admit, however, that I was not paying much attention. Miss Anne Elliot and it were finding amusement in discussing books.  I enjoyed it very much.  She is a very understanding young woman.”

Captain Harville laughed. “You and your books, man! You don’t meet ladies by discussing books!” Mrs. Harville smacked him playfully on the shoulder. “How would you know my dear husband! Just because I accepted a an ignorant man doesn’t mean that every woman would lower her standards that far!” She gave him a flirtatious grin and went off to check on the dinner preparations in the kitchen.

Harville laughed, then his face became serious. “Miss Louisa is very pleasant, but I don’t know about Wentworth’s feelings about her.  He certainly gives her the attention I would expect in an engaged couple and she obviously expects him to marry her, but he seems…I don’t know…I would expect Wentworth to be more warm when he fell in love.” I’m not explaining myself well.  He shook his head in frustration. 

Benwick sipped his ale. “Miss Louisa is indeed a very nice, open, friendly young lady, but there is much more to Frederick than parties and dancing. I cannot see Miss Louisa discussing music or the newest book.  I know he is ready to settle down and he is very ready to have a wife and family, and Miss Louisa would be a happy young bride, but will Frederick still be happy five years from now?” 

Harville nodded his agreement. “Exactly.  You have explained it well.  Unfortunately, it appears that he has already entangled himself.  I hope it turns out well for our friend.”

Benwick looked at him gravely, then took another drink from his glass.

 


 

Want to refresh your memory with Jane’s Austen’s original work? Read Persuasion on Austen variations HERE.

11 comments

Skip to comment form

    • Maggie Griscom on November 20, 2014 at 8:33 am
    • Reply

    Everyone knows but Frederick that Louisa isn’t the right wife for him. They are good friends to him.

    • Carol Settlage on November 20, 2014 at 9:43 am
    • Reply

    Thank you, Ms Pierson! This is a charmingly portrayed little glimpse into this warm-hearted family with good friends discussing and feeling concern for their fellow officer and friend. I agree with Maggie that they see the situation more clearly than Frederick… It does make it more surprising that Benwick later falls in love with the very girl he doesn’t think would appeal to a reading thinking man! Maybe you will write about that behind the scene event and help us understand how it evolved!? 🙂

    1. Thanks, Carol! I am hoping to follow their romance as it progresses!

    • Carole in Canada on November 20, 2014 at 3:17 pm
    • Reply

    Yes, his friends know him well and realize an appearance of commitment is almost there! We all know that Captain Harville has a discussion with Wentworth on this point. Oh what a tangled web Wentworth is weaving and he doesn’t even know it!

    1. So much easier for outsiders to see what is going on…unfortunately, as the visit goes on his friends over interpret Frederick’s actions and assume that they are actually engaged!

    • Deborah on November 20, 2014 at 5:24 pm
    • Reply

    Wonderfully done. Wentworth’s friends see Louisa as an imperfect match for him. Does he realize it yet? A tangled qwn indeed.

  1. As always, a terrific and wonderfully written segment, Carey! Thanks for sharing this new scene 🙂 .

    • Kathy on November 21, 2014 at 12:30 am
    • Reply

    It was very astute of Capt. Wentworth’s friends to note that he didn’t seem all that happy, even if he were attached to Louisa.

  2. Carey, I think you’ve captured their personalities beautifully-loved Mrs Harville too, who is largely ignored in the novel!

    • Sheila L. M. on November 21, 2014 at 4:07 pm
    • Reply

    “You’re mistaken if you think you have kept your intentions towards Louisa Musgrove a secret.” – says Harville to his friend Wentworth in the 2008 DVD version. And then Wentworth is surprised? I don’t care for this version but that sentence does say it all. He is then duty-bound to Louisa because of “expectations”. Benwick sees a lot but, it is strange that he fell in love with Louisa – perhaps subconsciously seeing his “ill” deceased fiancée in her and wanting to rescue her?

    I like the teasing between Harville and his wife.

  3. I like the banter between Mrs Harville and her husband. Thanks for giving us a fresh perspective on Wentworth’s marital prospects through the eyes of his two best friends, Carey.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.