Colonel Brandon and Elinor Dashwood – Part 1 – Mary Simonsen

 

Have you ever wanted to read how a conversation would go between Darcy and Captain Wentworth? Have you ever wished Caroline Bingley might make the acquaintance of Sir Walter Elliot? Have you ever thought Mrs. Norris and Lady Catherine could be best buds? Then you’ll love March Madness where we combine characters from Jane Austen’s books in a way you may not have imagined or in ways you may have hoped. Find a comfy chair, grab a cuppa and a few biscuits, and join us for the fun!

 

 

Colonel Brandon rose, indicating that his visit had come to an end. Elinor could easily imagine the reason: Marianne had kept to her room for the entire length of his visit. A month earlier, prior to his leaving for London, the Colonel had called at Barton Cottage. At that time, Marianne had come into the parlor for a mere ten minutes before mumbling an excuse about writing to some unnamed relation. As her sister spoke, Elinor had looked away so as not to see the disappointment in the Colonel’s eyes.

“May I walk with you to the gate, Colonel?” Elinor asked.

The Colonel smiled and gestured for Elinor to go ahead of him. Once on the path, he assured her that she should not be troubled on his account over Marianne’s absence. “The reason I call so often is that, for a time, I was genuinely concerned about Miss Marianne’s physical and…for her welfare, but after my last visit, all concerns fell away. She is hale and hearty and no longer in need of my attention. The reason I came today to Barton Cottage is that Margaret is a delight, your mother is a most gracious hostess, and I savor our conversations. In other words, I did not come to see Miss Marianne. Rather, I came to visit with the Dashwood family.”

Although pleased by the sentiment, Elinor found it difficult to believe, and the Colonel sensing her disbelief elaborated. “You doubt me, Miss Dashwood, and with good reason. But things have changed, and if you will bear with me, I would like to explain.”

Elinor iColonel Brandonndicated that the Colonel should proceed.

“Previously, I spoke to you of my grande passion for my father’s ward, Eliza, who was forced into a loveless marriage with my brother. Do you remember our conversation?”

“Of course, I remember it. You spoke of Eliza whenElinor you revealed that John Willoughby had fathered a child by her daughter.”

“The attributes that drew me to Eliza—a warmth of heart and an eagerness of fancy and spirits—also drew me to Miss Marianne. I had only to watch your sister at the pianoforte to know that a fire burnt within her. Being of a reserved nature, I was overwhelmed by her natural exuberance—her ability to make the most of every minute of every day. For someone, such as I, the attraction proved irresistible. Of course, any hope I entertained of engaging her attention disappeared with the arrival of Willoughby.”

Elinor nodded in understanding but insisted that Marianne’s attachment for John Willoughby would be severed in a moment if the Colonel would release her from her promise not to reveal that Willoughby had fathered a child by the Colonel’s ward.

The Colonel laughed. “Do you honestly think that such knowledge would result in a transfer of affection? I assure you that it would have quite the opposite effect. Marianne would forever resent me for exposing her lover for the scoundrel that he is.”

“That is only because my sister believes that you must ‘suffer for love’ or it is not true love. Considering the events that transpired in London, I would think Marianne has suffered sufficiently even for her and that she would look elsewhere—for someone who is steady and honest.”

The Colonel acknowledged the compliment with a nod. “Until recently, I thought it my destiny to suffer as well. First Eliza and then Marianne. Marianne’s unhappiness as a result of Willoughby’s vile treatment of her resulted in my own descent into melancholy. I found the only remedy for my unhappiness was a visit to Barton Cottage.”

Elinor started to say something, but the Colonel stopped her.

“Before you apologize for Miss Marianne’s failure to return my affection, I must say that I no longer want it.”

Elinor went wide-eyed. If the Colonel was no longer in love with Marianne, then why had he come to Barton Cottage on so many occasions? Surely, his claim that he found the company of the Dashwood ladies delightful was a mere excuse for his wish to see Marianne.

“I can see that you are trying to puzzle through my change of heart. Therefore, please allow me to explain. In looking for a companion, I found myself drawn to exotic birds of paradise—birds so rare that they would fight to be free of societal encumbrances–and dullards. It was then that I realized what I actually needed for my own happiness was not an exotic species but rather a perfectly delightful English songbird—a bird found right here in Devon.”

Now thoroughly confused, Elinor nodded as if she understood, but she did not.

“Miss Dashwood, I am not the only one who has suffered for love. Because of your affection for Mr. Ferrars, you, too, are suffering—”

“Colonel, when speaking of my regard for Mr. Ferrars, you must use the past tense. It is true that I did suffer, but now I have reached a place where I understand that everything has worked out for the best.”

“How so? I thought…” The Colonel shook his head. Now, it was his turn to be skeptical. Although curious, he had no right to pry. “I have no business asking you about so personal a matter.”

“That is very kind of you, Colonel Brandon. But if you will allow me, I would like to speak of my own transformation.”

As they stood by the gate, Elinor explained that she had had ample time to reflect on her attachment to Edward Ferrars. Even though he had given every appearance of being a man in love, he had never made a promise of any kind about a future together. She could not affix blame when nothing had been settled between them. Even so, she felt herself ill used. But in hindsight, Edward’s treatment of Elinor paled in comparison to his treatment of Miss Steele. While Lucy had whiled away her time in Plymouth, waiting for that day when she could make their engagement public, Edward had been engaged in one delaying tactic after another as well as a flirtation with her. In Elinor’s mind, he had not acted in a gentlemanly manner.

“Is this how you truly feel?” a surprised Brandon asked.

Elinor assured him that it was. “I know Edward was young at the time of his engagement, but surely with the passage of four years, he should have made it known to Lucy that he no longer had feelings for her and wished to be released from their engagement. She may have held him to his promise–in fact I think she would have–but at least he would have been honest with her. In return for a promise of marriage, she had spent the first bloom of her youth waiting for Edward, and she was determined to be rewarded for her patience. I never really a chance.

“If that is the case, then I have something to tell you.”

Part 2 will be posted tomorrow. All comments are appreciated. Thank you.

 

 

 

48 comments

Skip to comment form

    • Julie on March 8, 2016 at 1:56 am
    • Reply

    Ohhh – I hope it’s what I think it is. I’ve always felt that Elinor and Colonel Brandon ought to be together!

      • Meg on March 8, 2016 at 8:51 am
      • Reply

      I agree!

      1. Meg, We are on the same page. Thanks for commenting.

          • Ann Garland on March 11, 2016 at 2:47 am
          • Reply

          I agree with Julie, Meg, and Mary Simonsen.

      • Mary Simonsen on March 8, 2016 at 3:16 pm
      • Reply

      I agree, Julie. I think the Colonel fell in love with the “idea” of Marianne. His temperament is better suited to Elinor. Thanks for commenting.

    • Debra Perrin on March 8, 2016 at 2:54 am
    • Reply

    Oh, that’s a pairing I’d not thought of before….

    1. If you think of their similar temperaments, I think the Colonel and Elinor are a good fit.

    • Cynthia on March 8, 2016 at 3:27 am
    • Reply

    They would make a delightful couple!! I will be waiting for the second part!!😀

    1. Thanks, Cynthia. I agree. They would make a delightful couple.

  1. I’ve seen this pairing before, and like it.

      • Stephanie L on March 8, 2016 at 9:40 am
      • Reply

      Where? I would buy it if I could find it!

      1. I believe it wasn’t on fanfictiin.net. If I can locate it, I’ll post a link.

        1. I was wrong, it’s on dwiggie. Here is the link. http://www.dwiggie.com/derby/mercy2.htm

    1. Glad you like it. I think it makes sense.

    • Deborah on March 8, 2016 at 4:47 am
    • Reply

    What a delicious read. I am rarely anticipating tomorrow’s post. Will part 2 have what I hope it will? It would be so sweet.

    1. Thanks, Deborah. The post ran longer than the norm, and so I decided to break it in two. Glad you enjoyed it.

    • Glynis on March 8, 2016 at 6:21 am
    • Reply

    Hmmm well I never saw that coming and I must say that if I’m correct then that would be wonderful😊

    1. It’s good when a reader is kept guessing. Or at least that’s how I feel. I read a lot of mysteries.

    • Carol hoyt on March 8, 2016 at 7:19 am
    • Reply

    Liking this! I felt they had do much in common.
    I secretly wished the colonel wanted elinor instead if Marianne.

    1. It does make sense. They DO have so much in common–maturity for one. Thanks for commenting.

    • Kristine Shore on March 8, 2016 at 7:26 am
    • Reply

    Such a cliffhanger!

    1. 🙂

    • Maggie on March 8, 2016 at 7:46 am
    • Reply

    I always thought Elinor fit better with the Colonel than Marianne. I agree Edward did not behave as a true gentleman would.
    I loved this post but seeing Alan Rickman as Brandon, my favorite Brandon, is very sad. How wonderful he was in that role! I am ready for the rest of this story.

    1. The whole time I was writing this I thought about Alan Rickman. What a loss! He was enormously talented. Thanks for commenting.

    • Martine on March 8, 2016 at 8:42 am
    • Reply

    sounds interesting! agree with others that I always secretly wondered if elinor and Colonel Brandon were better suited to each other.

    I have always felt that Edward got off easy in the book.. it was pretty rude to keep lucy waiting for years. He certainly did lead her on even after he’d met Elinor. He wore the ring with her hair in it. I believe he only recently received the lock of hair from her. He likely would have had to have it set in the ring himself, and if not he still chose to wear it. He must have liked her enough to do that. I can see why Lucy is lead on.

    1. I agree, Martine. Four years! That’s a lot to ask of any woman and then to come up short! I think not. Thanks for commenting.

    • Stephanie L on March 8, 2016 at 9:40 am
    • Reply

    Oh be still my heart. This is one of my dearest JAFF wishes. *Stephanie doing a dance*

    1. 🙂

    • Sheila L. M. on March 8, 2016 at 10:31 am
    • Reply

    I agree with the others. Two hearts best suited for each other.

    Looking forward to the next post. Thank you for this.

    1. As always, Sheila, thanks for commenting.

    • Cindy on March 8, 2016 at 11:16 am
    • Reply

    LOVE this!! I always wondered why Elinor accepted Edward when he was in no way gentlemanly toward her or her feelings. I am reading a fanfic where Elinor ends up with Colonel Fitzwilliam and Colonel Brandon with Jane Bennet. I am enchanted. 🙂

    1. As you are receptive to cross-overs, you’ll love March Madness. Thanks for commenting.

    • Stephanie Carrico on March 8, 2016 at 1:10 pm
    • Reply

    While I love all of Jane Austen ‘s work, I feel every time I read S&S that Elinor and Colonel Brandon are so much better suited, I would enjoy see them paired, can’t wait to see what tomorrow brings.

    1. Thanks, Stephanie. I first read S&S when I was 17, and I thought Marianne was a poor match for the Colonel, probably b/c we were the same age. My opinion hasn’t changed.

  2. Yes, I agree with all of the comments above that the Colonel would have suited Elinor far better than Edward Ferrars whom, although not truly a cad, did not act as a man of honor (and the clergy) should have in his pursuit of Miss Dashwood while engaged to Lucy. Well, he didn’t really *pursue* Elinor, but neither did he lock his heart away to save them both much pain, as he should have.

    I’m very much looking forward to Part 2!

    Thank you!!

    Warmly,
    Susanne 🙂

    1. Thank you, Susanne. I couldn’t have said it better.

  3. Isn’t it tomorrow yet? I’m so ready for part 2. I imagine I have already figured out how the story will go, but I enjoy being proved wrong.

      • Mary Simonsen on March 8, 2016 at 4:48 pm
      • Reply

      Thanks, Joy. I can feel the enthusiasm. I appreciate your comment.

  4. Ooh- nice! I always thought the Colonel and Elinor were well suited to each other as well (although it always makes me happy when Edward finally gets his act together). I can’t wait to read the next installment!

      • Mary Simonsen on March 8, 2016 at 6:34 pm
      • Reply

      Although Edward comes through in the end, it really has nothing to do with him. It’s Lucy finagling a romance with his brother. Thanks for commenting.

    • Kara Louise on March 8, 2016 at 6:40 pm
    • Reply

    Mary, if you saw my comment yesterday on our Facebook page, you’ll know this is what I always felt should happen (at least I think it is if that’s where you’re going with this!) Col B and E are much better suited for each other! Nicely done!

      • Mary Simonsen on March 8, 2016 at 11:48 pm
      • Reply

      I agree. Austen certainly grew as a novelist. S&S has a lot of weak points, but the writing is brilliant.

    • Carol on March 8, 2016 at 9:28 pm
    • Reply

    Three peas in a pod! Three characters played by three great actors. Can’t wait for Part 2. Really great ties for your characters’ meeting. Now they need to think why their in the mess they’re in!

      • Mary Simonsen on March 8, 2016 at 11:48 pm
      • Reply

      Thanks, Carol. See you tomorrow.

    • Anji on March 9, 2016 at 2:08 am
    • Reply

    I held off reading commenting on this part because I wanted to read both parts back to back. Main comment on part two.

    • EvelynTost on March 9, 2016 at 4:19 pm
    • Reply

    This is wonderful! And I could hear Alan Rickman’s voice as Colonel Brandon the whole time!! Well, since I am a day late, I will rush to Part 2. Yay!!!

    • Ann Garland on March 11, 2016 at 3:07 am
    • Reply

    As an aside, I wonder what would have happened if the Dashwoods’ half brother had NOT chosen the woman he married? I detest that woman,and I think that he would have been a better brother if he had married someone else.

      • Julie on March 11, 2016 at 3:18 am
      • Reply

      I think that there’s no question that you’re right, Ann. When he first thinks of what to do for his father’s daughters, he comes to a very generous idea, but little by little, “that woman” talked him out of it. If he’d had a better partner, he’d have been a better man, but he is too malleable and weak.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.